Fraud Story 5 – Unveiling a Logistics Conspiracy: A Comprehensive Examination of Fraudulent Practices

Part 1: Execution of Contracts with Transport Vendors

The foundation of any sound logistics operation lies in the establishment of contracts with reliable transport vendors. Here, contracts were ostensibly signed with vendors of various capacities, including the perpetrating entity, to obfuscate any suspicions. Notably, some contracts were deliberately left unsigned, while others were allowed to expire without renewal. Rates for transportation were intricately tied to factors such as vehicle size, weight, and destination, creating a complex web of deceptive possibilities.

Part 2: Strategic Deployment of Trucks in Proximity to the Factory

At the core of the fraudulent operation was the strategic placement of trucks near the factory. Operating within the unorganized sector, these trucks engaged in undisclosed agreements with transport companies. Covert manipulation ensured that trucks associated with the perpetrating entity would be selected for stock pick-ups.

Part 3: Manipulation of Truck Allocation Procedures

The company operated on a system where the rates of the top three vendors would be displayed based on the trucks entering the factory for the pickup of goods. While the top three rates were visible, the discretion to choose the vendor for the pickup rested with the booking desk. However, a critical shift occurred in this process.

The individual at the booking desk was directed to select a specific vendor, one that had been pre-determined. Ameer, the logistics head, played a pivotal role in this manipulation. To fortify this deceitful manoeuvre, Ameer altered the system controls, ensuring that selecting the 2nd or 3rd highest-priced vendor wouldn’t trigger the standard workflow process. This manipulation was facilitated by the admin access granted to Ameer at the tool’s inception.

It is noteworthy that these alterations to the system controls took place months before the orchestrated events unfolded. This deliberate timing was aimed at veiling the fraudulent activities. Regrettably, Raja, the individual operating the booking desk, remained unaware of the intricacies of the system, unknowingly becoming a pawn in Ameer’s orchestrated scheme. In essence, Raja played the role of a puppet, unwittingly contributing to Ameer’s deceptive plan.

Part 4: Artful Manipulation of Material Loading onto Trucks

Before loading materials onto the trucks, the process involves recording the tare weights followed by the determination of gross weights, ultimately yielding the net weight. However, a manipulative practice came to light with trucks affiliated with the fraudulent vendor.

Drivers of these trucks received explicit instructions to artificially decrease the tare weight by removing additional items from the truck, relocating them near the gate. Subsequently, just before recording the tare weight, these items were reintegrated, artificially inflating the tonnage of the materials being transported. They orchestrated this deceptive maneuver to escalate the rates, as higher tonnage directly translated to increased transportation costs.

Part 5: Investigative Measures Undertaken by the Internal Audit Team

The unravelling of this intricate plot began with a thorough examination by the internal audit team, employing a range of investigative measures:

  • Scrutiny of unsigned or unrenewed contracts revealed irregularities.
  • Unexplained surges in business shares for specific vendors triggered further investigation.
  • Due diligence on vendors exposed concealed linkages and potential conflicts of interest.
  • Discrepancies in transportation rates implicated the preferred vendor in the fraudulent scheme.
  • Arbitrary vendor selection by the booking desk underscored potential misconduct.
  • Rigorous testing of system controls uncovered deviations from standard protocols.
  • Analysis of truck weights over time revealed patterns indicative of manipulation.
  • Extended residency of trucks within the factory premises beyond stipulated timelines raised suspicions. In a few cases, trucks would take 1 day from tare weight to gross weight recordings.
  • Frequent breaches of Turnaround Time (TAT) for deliveries provided additional evidence of wrongdoing.

Ameer’s calculated orchestration and Raja’s unwitting complicity painted a vivid picture of betrayal within the ostensibly routine logistics landscape. This expose serves as a cautionary narrative, illustrating that even in structured environments, meticulous deception may lurk in unexpected corners, awaiting exposure through the diligent efforts of those committed to upholding integrity and uncovering the truth.

About VMS 36 Articles
An Internal Auditor by profession and passionately taking my baby steps into data science with hope to contribute something valuable to the society someday. This blog is a long time dream and thanks to the lock down due to the pandemic it sees it's fruition. My posts will predominantly be on Internal Audit & Data Analytics & related posts, but will also have useful posts & quizzes related to courses relevant to the main topics & also certain irrelevant topics on my travel, music, movies and few other things I try my hands on. Hoping my posts help you learn new things, inspire you to do new things if not somewhat enjoyable. Happy Reading ! Connect with me here > https://www.linkedin.com/in/meenakshi-sundaram-b18a4399/

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.